Fast answer
A Polignano day trip from Monopoli works best when Monopoli remains the luggage base and Polignano gets a focused rail day for cliffs, viewpoints, the compact old town, and a short sea-facing visit. The plan should be built around current departures and returns, not static train times or a promise that every traveler can improvise the same day.
If you only do one thing
Default to sleeping in Monopoli, checking the current train options, and treating Polignano as a focused day rather than a reason to move hotels. That keeps dinner, luggage, beach alternatives, and the next morning simpler while still giving Polignano enough space to be the main excursion of the day.
Compare relevant booking options